Rothys vs Birdies: Brand Showdown
While researching for this Rothys vs Birdies shoe review, we found that Rothys stands out for its firm stance on sustainability. Rothys has sustainability as its mantra and treats its materials, production process and employees with a sustainable eye to create five lovable silhouettes for adults and children.
The concept for the Birdie shoes was born from the experiences of two busy moms who needed a comfortable, pragmatic and stylish shoe to fulfill their unmet needs. Designed with innovation to offer women comfort and elegance, the Birdy is unique with its 7-layer cushioning technology.
The following comparative Rothys vs Birdies shoes review will highlight the key elements of the brand and its products to help you make an informed buying decision.
Rothys vs Birdies Flats
Rothys Flats
The Rothys Flat is the shoe that got the ball rolling. Rothys shoes make you feel at ease, giving your foot the confidence to tackle the day without hesitation. The signature Rothys fabric gives you the feeling of security in the heel area and room to move in the toe area, with minimal stretch over time. Rothys offers its shoes at prices ranging from $169 to $209 in classic and offbeat colors as well as a merino wool collection.
The Rothys flat shoe is a high performance shoe that will give you confidence in all your endeavors, but perhaps most importantly, the flat shoe is made from eco-friendly materials in Rothys sustainable manufacturing facility. A snapshot of this amazing process shows Rothy’s signature yarn, which is made from recycled plastic water bottles.
As you read this Rothys vs Birdies shoe review, think about what an amazing achievement this is for our oceans and ecosystem! Rothys also makes the insoles from bio-based algae strobel sheets. Each material is carefully and meticulously selected.
Rothys not only support all your daily needs, but are also practical and easy to care for. You can put your Rothys in the washing machine after a work trip or let your little ones play in mud and sand and polish up the look of your Rothys with ease. Rothys are durable and made to last.
Washing instructions for Rothys
Remove the insoles
Place the insoles and shoes in the washing machine
Wash on a cold gentle cycle
Rothys do not react well to heat, so do not put them in the dryer.
Birdies Flats
In the first weeks of spring, when feet have been protected by boots for months, they are not used to the cut of an apartment. It’s not uncommon to have to tape your foot with band-aids to get you through your first walk. If you’ve had this terrifying and memorable experience, then the Birdies Flat is for you.
It combines the ultimate comfort of a slipper with the stylish look of a tasteful apartment. You’ll feel like you’re walking on air in the Birdies flat. In a variety of styles, from vegan velvet to suede, calf hair to leather, your Birdies will stand out with their elegant lines and sleek, feminine design, priced between $95-$165.
You work hard day in and day out; treat your feet – you deserve it! One element that weighs heavily in this Rothys vs Birdies shoe comparison is Birdies’ sensational 7-layer Cloud technology. Once you’ve sunk into them, you’ll never look back. You’ll feel like a queen in the soft, quilted satin, dual-layer, high-density memory foam, shock absorption and arch and heel support. With the Birdies Flat, you’ll strike the balance between a cutting-edge flat, the support you can rely on in your best slip-on, and the feeling of comfort you get when you step into your plushest s
Rothys Loafer
For this Rothys vs Birdies shoe review, we found Rothys’ loafers to be effortless, comfortable and casual. The Rothys is crafted in classic solid colors and eye-catching patterns to match your everyday attire. It’s perfect for traveling, routines or a dressy dinner out for $223 – $263. The loafer gives new life to an old favorite shoe. It’s a shoe that just works. Rothys guarantees your comfort with its signature yarn, and you can boast the benefit of eco-friendly fashion. If you spend a whole day walking on a trip to a new city, that’s no problem: the Rothys slipper is washable. You’ll continue to look good in this durable shoe.
The Point, in bold statement colors, is delicate in its flattering design and accentuated lines, but durable, at a price point of $196-$236. The Point is the intersection of style and comfort. If your foot is wider than a B, Rothys recommends sizing up one size in the Point. The Rothy Point’s meticulous craftsmanship will ensure that the shoe will be the linchpin of your style for many memorable occasions.
Quality
Another important category in this Rothys vs Birdies shoe comparison is quality. Rothys have a zero break-in period. Rothys team is committed to being the most comfortable shoe in your closet. Fit is important to Rothys; they are self-proclaimed fit freaks who insist you get it just right, with a little wiggle room for your toes in the front and a secure feel in the heel so you walk just right. Rothys makes its shoes from environmentally friendly materials. This goal can be achieved because Rothys has its own sustainable production facility.
We’re not done yet – Rothys has a signature theme. This helps them to know their shoes from front to back. Hand-picked, eco-friendly materials are used for the insole, taking care of your comfort. Rothys are durable to begin with, but the ability to wash the shoes extends their life and keeps you looking good and looking your best.
Birdies take you from “coffee to cocktails”. Their rich fabrics are timeless. With a durable sole that can be worn outdoors, you can get dinner ready and then head out the door without a single transition. With a wide range of materials, from velvet to suede and leather to faux fur, Birdies has everything to complete your look.
Did you say seven layers of comfort? The truth is, Birdies has mastered the slip-on and the fashion statement shoe all in one. Carefully researched and crafted, Birdies’ seven-layer interior will keep you so comfortable you’ll forget you’ve left the comfort of your bedroom behind. Birdies don’t compromise; they’re good at both – support and fashion.
Birdies: 7-layer padding
- Shock absorbing cushioning
- Two-layer memory foam with high density for cushioning the ball of the foot area
- Breathable Poron comfort cushioning
- Increasing arch support
- Pressure-reducing heel
- Signature satin quilting
Winner: Rothys
Did you know that Rothys are proudly worn by Gretchen Rubin, author of The Happiness Project? They really are quality that promotes quality of life! In this comparison between Rothys and Birdies, both shoes offer divine comfort, ethics and excellent quality, but Rothys offer a well-rounded quality.
It’s impossible to deny the seven-layer cushioning of Birdies, but Rothys excels in balance. All of their shoes are eco-friendly, and they prioritize fit. They’re nerds for the kind of perfect fit that works first time. There’s no mistaking that their shoes are durable, and that’s evident in the washability of the shoes. We think Rothys rock.
Customer Ratings
Rothys customers reported poor customer service and emphasized that it was difficult to get in touch with a customer service representative and that it was difficult to navigate the website. Customers also complained that the website did not have their size in certain shoes. Other customers stated that they love Rothys shoes and own several pairs. Customers also had negative experiences with shipping.
Customers said that while Rothys shoes were worth the price, they were too expensive and that the price was a barrier to buying more shoes. Customers described the shoes as durable and loved that they could put them in the washing machine. Customers also said that they could walk ten miles a day in their Rothys without feeling uncomfortable.
Birdies customers say they can’t stop buying the shoes, each pair seems to get better than the last. Customers are amazed at the duality of beauty and comfort of the shoes. They love supporting a company run by women for women and feel the care and shared experience in every pair of shoes. Customers felt that Birdies shoes were a good value. The free shipping and free returns tipped the scales in favor of the purchase. The customer service was described as amazing.
Winner: Birdies
Meghan Markle’s Birdies slippers are the winners. Terrible customer service reports tarnished the Rothys brand, which must be taken into consideration when evaluating Rothys and Birdies shoes. They were so bad that many customers vouched that they would not buy a pair of shoes through the company.
In addition, a review of Rothys vs Birdies shoes reveals that price was a barrier for Rothys customers. Birdies customers couldn’t say enough about the sensational shoe, excellent price and great customer service.
Shipping & Returns
Rothys Shipping
- Standard shipping takes 5-9 working days.
- It is always free of charge; Rothys understands that sizing can be a challenge
- Track your order via your account or the Order Status Finder
Birdies Shipping
- Ground shipping in the USA is free, and you will receive your items within 5-7 business days.
- Birdies are shipped to Canada, Australia and the UK.
- Shipping to Canada costs $10
- Shipping to the UK and Australia costs $20.
- International orders can take 7 to 15 days.
- Birdies does not offer free return shipping for international orders, but will refund your purchase price if you return the shoes.
- Contact help@birdies.com for the shipping address.
- Birdies charges duties and taxes at checkout
- Birdies will send you a shipping confirmation with a tracking number after you submit your order
Rothys Returns
- You can return unworn, unwashed shoes in their original packaging within 30 days of receipt.
- You can try the shoes on, but please only wear them indoors.
- For a limited time, Rothys is offering free return shipping on Canadian orders, but the company does not currently offer exchanges on Canadian orders
Return or exchange in person: Visit a ‘Happy Returns Return Bar’.
Return or exchange online: Visit the ‘Returns Center’.
Return or exchange in store: 2448 Fillmore Street in San Francisco
Birdies Returns
- Birdies accepts returns or exchanges on unworn Birdies within 30 days of receipt.
- In the USA, Birdies offers free returns and exchanges.
- Once you receive a shipping label, Birdies has 14 days to receive your order.
- If you choose to exchange, Birdies will ship your new items 1-3 days after you return the original order
- Birdies does not accept exchanges or returns for worn items
Winner: Rothys
In a comparison between Rothys and Birdies shoes in terms of shipping and return flexibility, Rothys was the winner. Rothys’ standard shipping is always free, while Birdies’ international shipping comes at a cost. However, Rothys shipping time can be a bit slower. Also, Rothys has a more flexible return policy. There are three places where you can return your shoes, including a Happy Returns Bar.
Rothys gives its customers a 30-day return policy once they have received the shoes. At Birdies, there is an extra step in the process, and once customers receive the shipping label, they only have 14 days to return the item. In our comparison between Rothys and Birdies, Rothys has the most considerate shipping and return policy overall.
Price & Value
The winner: Birdies
When comparing price and value in this review of Rothys and Birdies shoes, Birdies shoes came out on top. While Rothys are beautiful, durable, well-constructed shoes, Birdies achieves the same level of comfort and elegance for less. The eco-friendly sustainability factor may increase the price of the Rothys product, but Birdies still offers vegan materials for the conscientious consumer.
Both products have remarkable performance, but Birdies comes with a margin of cost. Customers love Birdies shoes so much that they buy many pairs, and price is a factor that helps keep them invested in the value of Birdies.
We Choose: Birdies
We added up the results of these two leading brands and Birdies won the title in a single category. In the categories of shoes, customer reviews, and price and performance, Birdies came out a hair ahead of its competitor. It should be noted in this Rothys vs Birdies shoe comparison that Birdies won in 3/5 categories.
In this Rothys vs Birdies test, it was clear that thanks to the seven-layer cushioning and opulent design, Birdies is the shoe that women keep coming back to. One woman even explained that she got so used to the comfort of her Birdies that one day she left the house wearing a pair of slippers and only realized her mistake when her two-year-old pointed it out.
This comparison between Rothys and Birdies shoes has shown just how affordable Birdies are. Birdies perfectly combines comfort and high fashion with excellent customer service. It’s a likeable brand made by down-to-earth women for women.
If you’re not already tapping into a side screen to make your purchase, or planning a trip to a Birdies retailer near you, trust us – you’ll want to pick up a pair!
Next, check out our in-depth reviews for Rothys and Birdies.
